you may know it better as jiz, spunk, cum etc - does it seem obvious now or were you just being a tease ?

personally I think the correct term is "baby batter" as mentioned in this line from a well known novel

"He left the room and I quickly spat out the baby batter. A million swimming horses in my mouth - better there than chasing my eggs. Or anyones."

chocolate starfish is possibly better known as the rusty sherrifs badge, you know, the backdoor ? the boys entrance ? the hershey highway !